Best Diner in Central Ohio! Don’s Downtown Diner
Looking for one of the best burgers in Ohio? Don’s Downtown Diner in Bellefontaine is a must-visit for any true burger enthusiast. This small-town gem packs a big punch with its gourmet, made-to-order steak burgers that are as fresh as they are delicious. From the classic cheddar cheeseburger to creative options like the Portobello Burger or even the wild Sweet Matilda Challenge, Don’s offers something for every taste. With fresh-cut fries, indulgent malts, and unique burger toppings, your taste buds are in for a treat at this hidden Ohio hotspot! You will want to check out the best burgers in central Ohio!
The Burgers at Don’s Downtown Diner
At Don’s, they don’t mess around when it comes to burgers. Every patty starts with a hefty half-pound of premium, fresh-ground steak that’s never frozen and always made-to-order. These burgers come standard with fresh tomatoes, lettuce, onions, pickles, and mayo, but you can customize them to your heart’s content. Bacon, grilled onions, or even a fried egg? You name it, they’ve got it.
My choice? A classic cheddar cheeseburger with the standard fixings. One bite, and I was in burger heaven. Juicy, flavorful, and perfectly cooked—just thinking about it makes my mouth water. Paired with a side of crispy, fresh-cut shoestring fries, this burger experience was off the charts.
A Wild Choice: The Portobello Burger
Then I opted for something a little different—the Portobello Burger, a deluxe creation loaded with deep-fried portobello mushrooms, Swiss cheese, and their signature horseradish sauce, all on a perfectly toasted bun. Matt said, ” Judging by the look on your face after that first bite, you definitely made the right call.” I declared it one of her top three burgers of all time, rounding out her meal with hand-cut fries and a rich chocolate malt. Talk about a winning combo!”
Up for a Challenge? Meet the Sweet Matilda
For those with a big appetite and a sense of adventure, Don’s offers the Sweet Matilda Challenge. This behemoth features four half-pound burgers stacked between grilled cheese sandwiches, ham, bacon, and a mountain of fries. If you manage to finish it all in one hour, you’ll earn a free t-shirt and a coveted spot on their wall of fame. This towering 10-inch burger isn’t for the faint of heart—I decided to pass on this one to avoid a hospital visit later!
More Than Just Burgers
While burgers are the star of the show at Don’s, the menu offers plenty of other delicious options, from Philly cheesesteaks to gyros and salads. But if you’re looking to really shake things up, try one of their more adventurous burger toppings like grilled pineapple, jalapeños, or even peanut butter! Yes, you read that right—peanut butter. A friend of mine tried it and said it was surprisingly good.
Plan Your Visit to the Best Diner in Central Ohio
If you’re on the hunt for one of the best burger joints in Ohio, look no further than Don’s Downtown Diner in Bellefontaine. Whether you stick with a classic or get creative with your toppings, you’re in for a treat.
Don’s Downtown Diner
208 S. Main St., Bellefontaine, OH 43311
Open Tuesday-Saturday: 11:00 AM – 7:00 PM
In a town full of culinary surprises, Don’s Downtown Diner truly shines as a must-visit for burger lovers. Whether you’re keeping it classic or craving something adventurous, their flavorful, made-to-order burgers and fresh-cut fries are sure to hit the spot. With a menu that’s as bold as it is delicious, Don’s adds to Bellefontaine’s growing reputation as a food lover’s paradise. So, next time you’re passing through or planning a foodie road trip, make sure to stop by Don’s Downtown Diner — your taste buds will thank you!
Happy Road Trips!
Brandy
Pin for later!
